Why our brains miss opportunities to improve through subtraction

If, as the saying goes, less is more, why do we humans overdo so much?

How would you stabilize this Lego structure to support a brick placed on top? Photo: University of Virginia

In a paper, University of Virginia researchers explain why people rarely think of removing something as a solution when looking at a situation, object or idea that needs improving. Instead, people almost always add some element, whether it helps or not.

The team's findings suggest a fundamental reason for several problems: why people struggle with overwhelming schedules; why institutions become bogged down in red tape; and, of particular interest to researchers, why humanity is exhausting the planet's resources.

"It happens in engineering design, which is my main interest," said co-author Leidy Klotz. "But it also happens in writing, cooking and everything else -- just think about your own work and you will see it. The first thing that comes to our minds is, what can we add to make it better. Our paper shows that we do this to our detriment, even when the only right answer is to subtract. Even with financial incentives, we still don't think to take away."

Klotz, whose research explores the overlaps between engineering and behavioral science, collaborated with other researchers on a series of observational studies and experiments to understand the phenomenon.

When considering two broad possibilities for why people systematically default to addition -- they generate ideas for both possibilities and disproportionately discard subtractive solutions, or they overlook subtractive ideas altogether -- the researchers focused on the latter.

"Additive ideas come to mind quickly and easily, but subtractive ideas require more cognitive effort," co-author Benjamin Converse said. "Because people are often moving fast and working with the first ideas that come to mind, they end up accepting additive solutions without considering subtraction." The researchers think there may be a self-reinforcing effect. (National Science Foundation)

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Researchers wirelessly record human brain activity during normal life activities

Researchers are now able to wirelessly record the directly measured brain activity of patients living with (...)

Host, management, or microbial traits: Which is dominant in plant microbiome assemblages?

Shifts in plant microbiomes impact plant health.

Lightning and subvisible discharges produce molecules that clean the atmosphere

Bolts create reactive chemicals that affect greenhouse gases.

Engineers find ankle exoskeletons can greatly increase walking speed

Ankle exoskeleton system increased walking speed by about 40%.

Extinct 'horned' crocodile gets new spot on the tree of life

Study on Madagascar crocodile suggests that modern crocs likely originated in Africa.

Climate Change Shifts Earth's Axis

Melting glaciers redistributed enough water to cause the direction of polar wander to turn and accelerate eastward during the mid-1990s, according to a new study.